| Re: Singularity As Separate Entity -
10-25-2006, 05:10 AM
I would like to address some flaws in founding postulates of your theory. I have given some part of your theory in bold and then I’ve given the flaw.
When you mention your first characteristic that you attribute to singularity namely, Matter you say: Mass is a property of space-time universe. According to John Earman, mass cannot exist in singularity. If we define singularity as the origin but out of our space-time universe, we have to take it as a no-mass entity.
The Einstein formula for a mass in motion is;
m = m0 / sqrt (1-v 2/c 2)
Read the italic part of your statement: for a mass in motion. But to apply such relativistic formula you need relative motion and that too in space-time universe. Singularity was deprived of mass as you wrote according to John Earman: mass cannot exist in singularity. Then how will you apply a formula related with mass to Singularity which is massless. Further you assume that Singularity is out of our space-time but before that you said that mass is a property of space-time. Isn’t this a paradox?
I can give you one more drawback: According to Big Bang Theory quarks first appeared after cosmic inflation. The vacuum energy transforms itself to particles and anti-particles of matter in equal number. So at the beginning of time there was no mass present. Unless we assume that the ultra dense matter turned to pure energy before reformation to matter particle. We can as well assume that universe started with a burst of energy. With this assumption singularity does not have to contain mass.
In this conclusion you say that singularity does not contain mass that is in other words zero mass. But if mass m is zero then according to Einstein’s famous equation,
e = mc^2 if we put m = 0 then e = 0 which means singularity doesn’t has any energy. Then how come universe started with burst of energy from zero energy? Further Law of Conservation of energy doesn’t allows e = 0.
With these two flaws I come to a conclusion that Singularity is not massless but all mass is converted into energy. Only two things are infinite, one is the universe and other is human's stupidity. I doubt the former.
-A.Einstein |