[Tony Stanton]

Neutralino

To be honest, Tony, the thought process behind your theory is summed up in this sentence talking about the results of GPB:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tony
I believe the “motional” procession will give a higher value because True Relativity predicts that local spacetime is rotating with the Earth and not being dragged around by the Earth.

Yes I do believe the motional procession will be greater than expected. The fact that these results have been delayed time and time again point to the fact that these results don’t match what Einstein’s Relativity predicts.

It's not enough to say that "you believe" your theory will do such and such-- if you don't make quantatitive predictions, then it is useless to make such comments.

Do you realise how many physicists have worked on Einstein’s Relativity just to make the prediction? And you expect me to be able to work the math on such a complex experiment. Be serious! It is ridiculous to expect an amateur to tackle such a complex experiment but the expectation that spacetime is rotating with the Earth and not being dragged around by the Earth logically brings me to the conclusion that the motional procession with be greater than expected.

I agree with dleviwing and quanta07; sorry, but your theory just doesn't work for me!

They, and you have not come up with one logical reason as to why TR cannot be true. Just to dismiss it out of hand without investigating it shows that your mind is closed even to theories that are mathematically correct. If there was no way to test TR then that would be acceptable but TR is a testable theory.
Is it because you didn’t come with the idea that makes you think I can’t possibly be right?
Don’t just dismiss it, rip it apart, if you can!!!
Let’s see how good you, Dave and quanta07 really are!!!

Tony