Penrose’s “Many Places” Experiment
Sir Roger Penrose
Has though about something
For a very long time,
Ever since Paul Dirac told him in class about:
“…the superposition principle,
Whereby very tiny objects could be
In two places at the same time.”
This blurry flux even allows
An “infinite” number
Of locations simultaneously.
Yes, quantum mechanics works perfectly;
But, what leads to the world
At ordinary scales?
What collapses the quantum wave function?
Penrose believes he has
Identified the secret
That keeps the quantum genie
Bottled up in the atomic world,
A secret that was
Right in front of us all along.
It is gravity.
The flaw in the Copenhagen interpretation
That collapse is due to “observation”
Is that it has no basis in theory.
Gravity is the only one
Of the fundamental forces
That physicists have been unable
To explain in quantum terms,
Einstein trying for 30 years,
This perhaps being a clue that
Physicists are on the wrong path.
How would gravity affect
An object small enough to exist
In the borderland between
The quantum world of atoms
And the human world of visible objects?
There should be such a place where
The quantum approaches the classical.
An object about the size
Of a spec of dust might
Provide the perfect test.
At this scale, an object is small enough
To be strongly affected
By the rules of quantum mechanics
But large enough to observe directly.
If there was a way to observe the spec
Without disturbing it, we would see
Quantum strangeness laid bare:
A macroscopic thing
Sitting in two places at once.
Quantum theory is incomplete
Because it ignores the effects of gravity.
Gravity is so weak on atomic
Or subatomic scales
That most physicists leave it out,
But tiny objects should,
By Einstein’s theory,
Produce space-time warps, too.
If a dust spec is in two locations at once,
Each one should produce its own
Distortions in space-time,
Yielding two superposed
Gravitational fields;
Yet, it takes energy
To sustain these dual fields.
The higher the energy required
To sustain a system,
The less stable it is,
So, over time,
It tends to settle back
To its simplest, lowest, energy state,
That is, to just one object
Producing one gravitational field.
If Penrose is right,
Gravity yanks objects,
Perhaps above a certain size,
Back into a single location,
Without any need to invoke
Observers or parallel universes.
What is the degree of instability, though?
Electrons, atoms, and molecules
Are so small that their gravity,
And hence the energy,
Is negligible, and so they
Can persist that way “forever”.
Very large objects,
On the other hand,
Create such significant
Gravitational fields
That the duplicate states
Vanish almost at once.
For a dust spec,
The process takes nearly a second,
Long enough that it may be measured.
Is there an experiment?
Instead of a spec of dust,
Penrose would use a tiny mirror,
Bouncing radiation off it
To see if it was in one
Or two locations at the same time.
If Penrose is right,
The mirror would maintain
A dual existence for no more than a second
Before gravity chained it to a single location.
He initially wanted to use
An x-ray laser mounted
On a platform in outer space.
It would shoot photons
Towards a tiny target mirror
Tens of thousands of miles away.
A half-reflective mirror,
Called a beam splitter,
Would separate each photon
Into two states
So that it would follow two paths
At the same time.
On one path,
The photon strikes the tiny mirror,
Moving it slightly;
On the other,
It is reflected away
From the target mirror,
So the mirror does not move.
In the prevailing quantum view,
Both events occur simultaneously:
The mirror moves
And remains in place
A the same time.
On its return path,
The duplicate photon that struck the mirror
Hits the same mirror again,
Returning it to its initial position.
Since there is fundamentally
No way to tell which path
The photon took,
The two photons interfere with each other
And recombine into a single photon
That is always reflected along a path
Back toward the laser;
Thus, no x-ray photons
Can ever follow a path
That leads them to a detector
Which would be sitting off of
The first half-reflected mirror.
However, if as Penrose expects,
It forces the tiny mirror
To either remain at rest or move,
But not both,
Because gravity anchors
The tiny mirror to a single state;
Consequently, each photon
Will follow one path only.
So it cannot interfere with itself;
Half the time leading it to the detector.
Thus, the quantum duplicate
Of the mirror must have disappeared,
And so Penrose’s view of reality
Would be the correct one.
Well, there is too much expense
In performing the experiment in outer space,
So Dirk Bouwmeester
Has devised a way to bring
Penrose’s experiment down to earth.
A visible light source is to be used
Instead of an x-ray laser,
Giving it the same kick
By reflecting the light photons
Back and forth between
Two mirrors a million times.
They are past buckyballs now,
Soccer ball-shaped carbon molecules,
in size, up to an organic molecule
Called azobenzene,
Although the tiny mirror
Would be a billion times bigger.
They are working on ways
To shield the experiment
And students are creating the mirrors.
Stay tuned for a few more years.