| | | | The Thinker
Status: Offline Posts: 3,278
Thanks Given: 14
Thanked 9x in 9 Posts
Join Date: Mar 2005 Rep Power: 47 | 'The central Q. in philosophy is: Why is there something and not nothing?' Leibnitz -
06-03-2006, 06:02 PM
Quote: |
Originally Posted by Vabrugar Imagine, a human in an empty island creating a farm and a house. Can you relate farm as earth, house as heaven and island as a place where God was before He created heaven and earth? A place where no humans ever think of. | Is there any sense in inventing that other 'place'? I mean, don't you have enough by inventing god, morals, inmortality, infinity... That you need even to event somewhere which is not a where but simply another form or level of existence of which we don't or/and cannot know? And even assuming that god exists, is there any reason that makes be absolutelly sure (and I mean, that by pure logic you can prove there is possible alternative) that your particular view of the world--here talking about your believe in god--is the truth, is correct, is universal knowledge? Why must god have created everything? Why god must have created? Why not the world created god instead of god created the world? Why opposing those two forms, those two theological concepts of transcendence and immanence? Why even having those concepts, aren't they completelly misleading about what the being is (by giving wrong ideas as that there is a supreme being independent of nature, or that everything is not everything, or that infinity is independent of finity)? If we make any theological statement, we must re-consider all the terms and ideas used in such statement. Not from the theological point of view, nor from the metaphysical one, nor from the scientific one; but from the interpretation of texts, from topological (Freud's psicoanalysis) semiotics (Saussure's gramatology). And when we do so, we discover the not-so-importantness of the origin of events, objects and concepts, and we realize the so-importantness of the consecuence of those events, objects and concepts. | |
| | | | | | Fearless ToeQuest Leader
Status: Offline Posts: 814
Thanks Given: 14
Thanked 104x in 64 Posts
Join Date: Apr 2003 Rep Power: 30 | Re: Where was God before He created heaven and earth? -
06-03-2006, 06:16 PM
Quote: |
Originally Posted by Vabrugar Imagine, a human in an empty island creating a farm and a house. Can you relate farm as earth, house as heaven and island as a place where God was before He created heaven and earth? A place where no humans ever think of. | I agree that it is useful to have a backstage to reality that continues to exist before and after the play, but what is the nature of the backstage? "I'm going on a TOE Quest!" | |
| | | | | | Moderator
Status: Offline Posts: 7,340
Thanks Given: 348
Thanked 703x in 655 Posts
Join Date: Aug 2005 Rep Power: 94 | Re: Where was God before He created heaven and earth? -
06-03-2006, 07:21 PM
The nature of this "backstage" Robert,is unknowable to man in his present
stage in evolution,however this will not always be the case,as man evolves
and begins to express more and more of his inherit divinity,then withthe aid of a much expanded consciousnesss,and with further identification with the
whole,and with the idea of absolute inclusiveness nowfirmlyembedded in the
consciousness of the one who is waking into this new dawn,then there will
be the ability to see behind the screen,and witness the before?
kind regards michael. Humilty,coupled with boldness,surprises truth to
reveal herself? | |
| | | | | | Brown Belt
Status: Offline Posts: 170
Thanks Given: 7
Thanked 7x in 7 Posts
Join Date: Dec 2005 Rep Power: 11 | Re: Where was God before He created heaven and earth? -
06-04-2006, 02:27 PM
Hey all .. the mind is a shadow (thanks michael) and backstage is a projector .. lights .. camera .. action .. at least I think thats how it goes ..
And it all began with an "idea" .. in the "shadow" of the "minds eye" .. like every good book really ..
Ashley The fundamental method of philosophy is the use of reasoning to evaluate arguments concerning these questions .. | |
| | | | | | Master
Status: Offline Posts: 620
Thanks Given: 1
Thanked 4x in 4 Posts
Join Date: Nov 2005 Rep Power: 17 | Re: Where was God before He created heaven and earth? -
06-04-2006, 03:07 PM
You may think this slightly disrespectful, but I tire of the images that we are fed of the Almighty suffering, etc., or just creating and disappearing, hopefully not consumed in the process.
Actually, I imagine God suddenly feeling something gigantic and momentous coming over Him, giving in to the powers that came to be, and then sorting out just what the heck happened! Maybe a small moment of what have I done, and hopefully, long stretches of understanding, grace, and patience for all that are helplessly adoring, from near and far.
I mean no disprespect, please believe me. Honestly, I don't know where these feelings come from sometimes. Must I question the origin of that which comforts and soothes and reassures. That would be silly at best. | |
| | | | | | 6th degree Black Belt
Status: Offline Posts: 844
Thanks Given: 43
Thanked 15x in 15 Posts
Join Date: Jan 2006 Rep Power: 18 | Re: Where was God before He created heaven and earth? -
06-04-2006, 03:13 PM
Michelle,
I must have missed the image(s) of the Goddess suffering or disappearing altogether! The first is only interesting if it is the beginning of something. The first is not interesting if it is the only - Djanet Sears | |
| | | | | | Brown Belt
Status: Offline Posts: 170
Thanks Given: 7
Thanked 7x in 7 Posts
Join Date: Dec 2005 Rep Power: 11 | Re: Where was God before He created heaven and earth? -
06-05-2006, 06:36 AM
Quote: |
Originally Posted by Vabrugar Heaven may be an spritual world while earth is a material world. We know the bible said, God created heaven and earth. But where was God before He created heaven and earth? Any thoughts? | Okay so I have a few questions .. who is god .. ?? everyone speaks of this godly character .. and who knows for sure god exists as he is said to .. or she .. as the god/ess .. ??
Who said heavan and earth were created .. ?? Maybe they just appeared out of no-where ..  and are now-here ..
What is this heavan you speak of .. ?? And just for clarification would you please define for me .. "material" .. thanks .. Im blonde ..
Threads about God always confuse me .. hehe Quote: |
Originally Posted by Guille Is there any sense in inventing that other 'place'? I mean, don't you have enough by inventing god, morals, inmortality, infinity... That you need even to event somewhere which is not a where but simply another form or level of existence of which we don't or/and cannot know? And even assuming that god exists, is there any reason that makes be absolutelly sure (and I mean, that by pure logic you can prove there is possible alternative) that your particular view of the world--here talking about your believe in god--is the truth, is correct, is universal knowledge? Why must god have created everything? Why god must have created? Why not the world created god instead of god created the world? Why opposing those two forms, those two theological concepts of transcendence and immanence? Why even having those concepts, aren't they completelly misleading about what the being is (by giving wrong ideas as that there is a supreme being independent of nature, or that everything is not everything, or that infinity is independent of finity)? If we make any theological statement, we must re-consider all the terms and ideas used in such statement. | *nods* in agreement .. yes guille that is my point exactly .. a belief something exists .. holds no weight in theory .. and is simply an idea .. based on an assumption of .. the fundamentals of existance ..
Ashley The fundamental method of philosophy is the use of reasoning to evaluate arguments concerning these questions .. | |
| | | | | | The Observer
Status: Offline Posts: 1,804
Thanks Given: 26
Thanked 184x in 149 Posts
Join Date: Jan 2005 Rep Power: 36 | Re: Where was God before He created heaven and earth? -
06-05-2006, 01:33 PM
When humans created god, it was to provide answers to the unknown physical phenomena of their environment. Latter the concepts of a god became a political doctrine to control the social behavior of groups of humans just as it is being used today. It is the greatest money making scam of all human history and is only successful if you keep the majority of humans stupid enough to accept the dogma. David | |
| | | | | | The Thinker
Status: Offline Posts: 3,278
Thanks Given: 14
Thanked 9x in 9 Posts
Join Date: Mar 2005 Rep Power: 47 | Re: Where was God before He created heaven and earth? -
06-05-2006, 03:08 PM
Quote: |
Originally Posted by dleviwing When humans created god, it was to provide answers to the unknown physical phenomena of their environment. Latter the concepts of a god became a political doctrine to control the social behavior of groups of humans just as it is being used today. It is the greatest money making scam of all human history and is only successful if you keep the majority of humans stupid enough to accept the dogma. | Actually every single doctrine to control social begaviour in groups of humans requiers humans to keep certain (considerably big) amount of stupidity. God, money, and any other idle. | |
| | | | | | 9th degree Black Belt
Status: Offline Posts: 1,579
Thanks Given: 114
Thanked 44x in 42 Posts
Join Date: Jan 2006 Rep Power: 26 | Re: Where was God before He created heaven and earth? -
06-06-2006, 01:14 PM
Was god created by quantum accident, or metaphysical intentionality...?
regards "To develop the skill of correct thinking is in the first place to learn what you have to disregard. In order to go on, you have to know what to leave out; this is the essence of effective thinking." Kurt Godel "Time and space are modes in which we think and not conditions in which we live." Albert Einstein "The uncertainty principle is an absolute, finite, universal constant." L.G. "The tick-tick-tick of the cesium atom is a sliding-time-scaler constant of all finite universal motion." L.G. | |
| | |
Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests) | | | | Thread Tools | | | | Display Modes | Linear Mode |
Posting Rules
| You may not post new threads You may not post replies You may not post attachments You may not edit your posts HTML code is Off | | |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.8 Copyright ©2000 - 2008, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Content Relevant URLs by vBSEO 3.2.0
vBulletin Skin developed by: vBStyles.com | |