Causal Determinism -Where has the begining gone?

[austintorn@aol.com]

Sir Isaac Newton (SIN) is the grandaddy of Greg Isaac Graybeard and so Greg probably has the document in his basement somewhere.

[everymansmedium]

I'll give my interpretation,
I think the questions we are asking are the wrong ones,
Because who, when and where means there should be existence before we ask them.
When dictates the existence of time,
Where dictates the existence of space,
and who dictates the existence of a person(power)...
Then how can these questions be asked for a 'before existence' scenario?

Hello Mohan:
Because a logical answer to these question may shed a bit of light on existence. It is not like we are not sure of existence.
Are you sure that you exist?
I AM!
Then look at what we do know. For this is the only way to find answers to what we do not.
John

[Mohan.C]

I'm not sure I can answer the question of, who? mainly because I'm not sure who.
As to when? it would have to be 0th second, if the universe was created, but if the universe has just always been, then that's a bit of a problem

And where? Again it depends whether the universe was created at a time instant at a certain position ( I did not say point ) but this is how I have interpreted the creation of the universe.

see this link, its something I was trying to work with, its not a complete theory, its more of a speculation.
spacetime
its a link to one of the forum posts itself, and its not a very big post, so don't hesitate to check it out.

These are very tricky questions, mainly because the answers are always relative.